Tesla just unveiled a cheaper Model Y and Model 3. Why the stock is falling.

Tesla just unveiled a cheaper Model Y and Model 3. Why the stock is falling.

Referenced Symbols

Tesla Inc. has unveiled cheaper, pared-down versions of its two best-selling electric vehicles, in a bid to re-energize sales amid an expected slump after the end of U.S. tax credits for EV buyers.

The move did not sit well on Wall Street, however, with Tesla’s stock 

 

TSLA

-4.45%

 accelerating losses in the final hour of trading Tuesday, closing down 4.5%.

“We view the announcements as a big disappointment,” said Garrett Nelson, an analyst with CFRA.

“It can’t hurt from a sales volume perspective, but we think the announcement is a disappointment for investors desperately hoping for new models such as the long-awaited Roadster, and Tesla’s sales are still likely to drop meaningfully” starting in the fourth quarter, he said.

The company had teased the news with a pair of cryptic tweets over the weekend, but the newly announced trims still hover closer to $40,000 than $30,000 — a price that many investors view as putting the vehicle within mass-market reach.

Tesla also renamed its cheaper versions as “standard.” The Model Y trim will now sell for $39,990; until yesterday, the cheapest Model Y trim cost just under $45,000. For the Model 3 sedan, the standard trim now goes for $36,990.

The new prices also do not make up for expired federal tax credits worth up to $7,500 for certain EV buyers. The Biden-era incentives ended last month.

“With the end of the federal incentives, Tesla needed to fill the pricing gap,” said Sam Fiorani with AutoForecast Solutions. Starting under $40,000 for the Model Y standard “moves the brand into the range where buyers who needed the $7,500 tax credit would be comfortable,” he said.

Tesla is known for constantly shifting prices, Fiorani said. “Adding the lower priced model allows the previous entry-level Model Y to remain at its $45,000 level and keep the residual values relatively steady. The new model should keep the factories humming.”

The cheaper versions sacrifice some performance: The Model Y standard, for example, can go 321 miles between charges, and go from zero to 60 mph in just under seven seconds, according to Tesla’s website. That compares with a range of 357 miles and 0-60 mph in 5.4 seconds for the next trim up, “premium” with rear-wheel drive.

Tesla has been faulted for not launching an entirely new EV in looks and technology except for the Cybertruck, which has limited appeal and carries a price tag of around $80,000 for its cheapest trim. That price remains unchanged.

“One of the biggest reasons behind Tesla’s market-share losses is the staleness of its vehicle portfolio,” Nelson said.

In July, Tesla Chief Executive Elon Musk said that a stripped-down version of the Model Y, Tesla’s most popular vehicle, would be one of two long-awaited, cheaper models from the EV maker.

Source : marketwatch